Filing Flows › Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) › Stock forecast & fair value
Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) stock forecast and fair value
Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) trades at $99.89. 7 analysts' median price target is $105.00 (+5%), from $85.00 to $115.00. Across 15 valuation methods the middle fair value is $99.99 (+0.1%).
Fair value by method
| Method | Low | Point | High | vs price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P/E vs peers | $64.75 | $91.89 | $113.70 | -8% |
| P/E vs peers, weighted | $84.68 | $102.99 | $118.42 | +3% |
| P/E vs peers, matched | $75.34 | $99.99 | $118.30 | +0.1% |
| Residual income | $71.29 | $74.04 | $76.94 | -26% |
| P/B vs ROE (insurer peers) | $39.54 | $122.43 | $205.31 | +23% |
| Analysts' price targets | $85.00 | $103.86 | $115.00 | +4% |
| Shareholder yield (dividends + buybacks) | $50.78 | $60.44 | $74.64 | -39% |
| Justified P/B (Gordon growth) | $131.09 | $165.99 | $226.23 | +66% |
| Dividend discount (Gordon) | $33.94 | $42.97 | $58.57 | -57% |
| Stage-weighted value (financial (bank / insurer)) | $67.65 | $102.64 | $142.93 | +3% |
Selective Insurance Group's latest quarter
Selective Insurance Group, Q3 2026: revenue $1.3B (-2% year over year), operating margin 12.2%, net earnings $129M, operating cash flow $367M. The chart follows the revenue to costs, profit and cash.
Questions
What is the price target for SIGI stock?
The median of 7 analysts' 12-month targets is $105.00, +5% from $99.89; the range is $85.00 to $115.00. The average rating is hold.
What is Selective Insurance Group's fair value?
The fair-value methods on Filing Flows (DCF, Monte Carlo, peer multiples and others) put it between $41.34 and $165.99, with a middle value of $99.99 against a price of $99.89. Each method's assumptions are on the page.
Does Selective Insurance Group usually beat earnings estimates?
It beat the consensus EPS estimate in 60% of the quarters on record.
Is SIGI stock a buy?
Filing Flows does not give advice. It shows what analysts expect, what each valuation method implies and the figures behind them, read from SEC filings, so you can judge for yourself.
Updated Nov 8, 2026. Read automatically from SEC filings and public data; errors are possible. Not investment advice.